Broker/Agent Timothy M. McMahon, Jr. 

Tim M. McMahon Jr. - Your Trusted Northeast Ohio Real Estate Expert

Mentor Ohio Real Estate Agent You Can Trust

Top 10 Lake County Producer | 500+ Homes Sold | 20+ Years Experience

Whether you're buying your first home, upgrading, downsizing, or preparing to sell, working with the right real estate agent makes all the difference. In Mentor, Mentor-on-the-Lake, and Concord, Tim McMahon brings a proven track record of success, combining deep local market knowledge with strategic pricing, targeted marketing, and strong negotiation skills to deliver real results.

With over 500 homes sold and recognition as a Top 10 Lake County producer, Tim takes a hands-on, personalized approach with every client—ensuring clear communication, smart strategy, and a smooth experience from start to finish.

View Homes for Sale
Get Your Home Value
Demonstrated Success

Proven Results in Lake County Real Estate

When it comes to buying or selling a home in Mentor and surrounding communities, experience matters. Tim McMahon has built a reputation for delivering results, negotiating strong deals, and guiding clients every step of the way.

Read More Reviews
Recognized Excellence

Your Local Real Estate Expert in Mentor, Ohio

As a dedicated real estate agent serving Mentor, Mentor-on-the-Lake, Concord, and all of Lake County, Tim understands the local market better than anyone. From lakefront homes to family neighborhoods, he helps clients find the right fit.

See What We Offer
Local Expertise

Why Work with Tim McMahon?

As a top 10 producer in Lake County and top 250 producer in all of Northeast Ohio, I am a trusted resource with a prestigious reputation, industry knowledge and unwavering commitment to excellence, I consistently deliver for clients.

Schedule a Consultation

  • Tim was calm, cool, and collected throughout the entire process of listing and selling our home. His knowledge for the area of real estate surpasses all and we would highly recommend his services to all.

    Patrick T

  • Tim was able to help us prepare our home to be listed and sold for top dollar, while simultaneously aggressively searching for our next home. When he found what we were looking for he was able to secure an accepted contract for us on the first day amongst multiple bidders, and then was able to turn around and get our current home for sale and under contract within a week. He was able to time everything up for us so there was no rush or hassle on either transaction. We give Tim the highest recommendation possible for ability and character.

    Richard L

  • Tim was the most helpful realtor throughout our entire home selling process. He was very communicative, positive, and reassuring. He was very friendly and very helpful about everything that needed to happen and any questions or concerns we had. He went out of his way numerous times to help us sell our home. Definitely will be contacting him again for any future real estate needs!

    Nick D

  • Got more done in 1 day with Tim than in 1 year with my previous realtor. Extremely knowledgeable, friendly, and accessible. Fought to make sure I got the best deal possible.

    Louis N

  • I would highly recommend Tim to anyone looking to buy a new home. Tim was on top of everything throughout our entire purchase. He always worked to accommodate us and our schedule, but most importantly, answered any question I had and provided his honest opinion on every house we looked at. Which for me, was important, especially with being a first time home buyer. Thank you, Tim!

    Luke L

  • Tim is the best realtor I have ever met. I had moved to another state so he set up all repairs and kept me updated on all happenings. He went out of his way to accommodate all involved. He is a very ethical hard worker, and a nice person, too.

    Janet M